Re: Welders
Posted: Mon 19 Nov, 2007 10:09 pm
I agree that's very cheap - couple of comments though -
A) do you have a 15A circuit?
B) 4 position current control is pretty coarse - this might haunt you when your doing some work.
C) 20% duty cycle at 120A doesn't look too good to me, especially with fan cooling. I reckon get a lot closer to 50% at about 120A.
I'm sure it would be adequate for your needs, but it is a cheap MIG and you do get what you pay for.
For the purposes of comparison - here's a quality product. you might not be able to stretch to an ESAB, but this is a "professional" machine. Note, the 150A unit runs on a 10A plug and still claims 150A at 20% duty cycle. (ESAB don't rate their machines at 10% duty cycle- you won't get much work done at 30 seconds on.... 4.5 minutes off)
http://esabsp.esab.net/templates/docOpe ... 123320.pdf
As I said, I don't think the one you are looking at is a bad buy, but it is useful to compare with the real deal. A welder is a "lifetime" purchase - you should be welding stuff up with it in 20 years.
Steve.
A) do you have a 15A circuit?
B) 4 position current control is pretty coarse - this might haunt you when your doing some work.
C) 20% duty cycle at 120A doesn't look too good to me, especially with fan cooling. I reckon get a lot closer to 50% at about 120A.
I'm sure it would be adequate for your needs, but it is a cheap MIG and you do get what you pay for.
For the purposes of comparison - here's a quality product. you might not be able to stretch to an ESAB, but this is a "professional" machine. Note, the 150A unit runs on a 10A plug and still claims 150A at 20% duty cycle. (ESAB don't rate their machines at 10% duty cycle- you won't get much work done at 30 seconds on.... 4.5 minutes off)
http://esabsp.esab.net/templates/docOpe ... 123320.pdf
As I said, I don't think the one you are looking at is a bad buy, but it is useful to compare with the real deal. A welder is a "lifetime" purchase - you should be welding stuff up with it in 20 years.
Steve.